Disclaimer: I don’t like AI, so obviously I don’t take a neutral stance here.
I know that AI can be a useful tool in certain circumstances. For very important things, like health, it’s crucial to get an actual doctor’s opinion. The same holds true for topics regarding recovery. AI makes a lot of mistakes. A lot.
It can be very tempting to just take what AI says at face value because it’s designed to sound very confident in its responses, even if those responses are nothing more than AI “hallucinations”. Personally I think that’s extremely dangerous, it can be very misleading.
People all over the world are asking various AI chatbots questions about their health. I’ve read several news articles about AI diagnosing things doctors had missed. That’s great… when it works. But there are many more stories about AI chatbots giving horrible advice, causing great harm to individuals.
Then there is the affect of AI data centers has on local environments. These data centers require an insane amount of energy and water. I’ve read that just asking a single question to any AI chatbot consumes, at minimum, a bottle of water.
A single question. Imagine every person in the country asking just one question per day. That’s a minimum of 342 to 349 MILLION bottles of water per day.
People in recovery can be particularly vulnerable during certain points in recovery. We need help, and fast. Sometimes it can be the middle of the night or 3 AM and we need help right then. Unlike people, AI never sleeps. It’s always there.
It’s extremely tempting to open up the laptop or use the phone and ask an AI chatbot for help as if it were a person. AI is trained to mimic empathy. The key word is “mimic”. But it’s a machine. It has no feelings one way or another toward a suffering human being.
And as good as AI is at mimicking human emotions, it can be easy to forget that’s not a human on the other side, it’s a machine. It has no body so it has absolutely no interoception. With no interoception, it is utterly incapable of accurately guessing a human’s current emotional and physical state.
I write this because I know there are people out there who feel isolated and turn to AI. That’s why I think recovery groups are so vital. Recovery groups are both in-person and online. Real people, not machines. And those real people can provide something no machine ever could, true understanding through lived experience.
A machine has never felt afraid at 3 in the morning, experienced flashbacks from trauma, or desperately wanted a drug or alcohol.
A machine doesn’t know what any of that is like because it’s never experienced any of that. The people in recovery groups have. They KNOW what it’s like because they’ve experienced it themselves. They can help someone in ways no machine ever could.
I’m under no illusion that AI is going to disappear or that it doesn’t have its uses. But I’m also under no illusion that it knows what’s best for us or is even capable of WANTING what’s best for us.
As someone in recovery myself, I just want to encourage others to connect with real people, not machines. We are social creatures, we need each other. If you ever find yourself in great need and wanting to use or drink again and decide to use AI, please consider asking it about the nearest recovery group. That would be the best use of an AI chatbot at a time like that.
Amituofo
~Buck









